Tag Archives: The Genus Question

Nanotyrannus Nomore!?

Nanotyrannus is everyone’s favorite tyrannosaur, as long as it’s right behind the big guy, Tyrannosaurus, itself. It’s been lovingly depicted and aggressively championed by such notable figures as Robert Bakker, and supported less enthusiastically but no less masterfully by Philip … Continue reading

Posted in Paleontology, Science Reporting, Taxonomy | Tagged , , | 21 Comments

“Taste” Versus “Science”

My recent discussion on the value of “originalism” has led to some interesting comments from respondents Mickey Mortimer and Mike Taylor. As I respect both of them, but disagree, I will post their comments in full below and respond to … Continue reading

Posted in Philosophy, Taxonomy | Tagged , , | 4 Comments

Systematic Originalism

On occasion, systematists feel the need to revise the taxonomy of various species, placing species into new genera, or lumping them in with other species in earlier-named genera. This is generally supported by phylogenetic analyses, but sometimes it involves an … Continue reading

Posted in Paleontology, Philosophy, Systematics | Tagged , | 10 Comments

Splitting Chirostenotes

Seems audacious of me, eh? Chirostenotes (specifically, Chirostenotes pergracilis) enjoys one of the more interesting synonymy lists among dinosaurs, as it contains (or has contained) no fewer than three generic synonyms and four specific synonyms, but also that it has … Continue reading

Posted in Paleontology, Taxonomy | Tagged , , | 13 Comments

Ontogeny and Taxa

I’d promised some follow-up posts to two previous ones in which I describe other “issues” I perceived. The first was a continuation of what I felt was wrong about the argument of Scannella and Horner (here) in regards to their … Continue reading

Posted in Paleontology, Philosophy, Taxonomy | Tagged , , | 2 Comments

Horns, Frills, Knobs and Domes – Morphological Ontogeny

Recently I’ve been embroiled in a discussion with various professional paleontologists, interested scientists, and lay paleophiles on the topic of the synonymy proposed by Scannella and Horner [1] for the Hell Creek chasmosaurine ceratopsians Triceratops and Torosaurus. I feel it … Continue reading

Posted in Paleontology, Science Reporting, Taxonomy | Tagged , , , , | 1 Comment

Scare Quotes and Recent Ceratopsians

Scare quotes are a figurative use of quotation marks to imply the object(s) being enclosed (be it a theory, phrase, or word) are not proscribed by the quoting author(s) [n1]. In this case, they are used around taxonomic names that … Continue reading

Posted in Biology, Paleontology, Science Reporting | Tagged , , , | 3 Comments